Monday, November 26, 2012

LEGO Power Functions incompatibilities

Some of us have been behind the scenes for a while, dealing with the latest issue found on the LPF family...

At mid October a Polish AFOL found one potential problem with the new PF V2 Receiver (released with the 9398, 4x4 Crawler) when there are two PF M-motors connected to one of its outputs.

The issue can be put shortly like this - When two or more Medium motors are connected to a single output of the V2 Receiver (no matter which one), they often make a squeaking sound instead of starting, and only start after some time, or if forced by hand. Even after they finally start and then stop, the problem occurs again.

Today after having concluded their own investigations, the Technology Platform Team came-up with one official statement about this issue, signed by Gaute Munch as usual.



LEGO Power Functions V2 RC Receiver

There has been some confusion regarding the new LEGO Power Functions V2 RC Receiver that is released in the Technic 9398 4X4 Crawler. This component is currently only available through the 9398 set, but was not made exclusively for this product.

The V2 RC Receiver is updated with a CMOS motor driver giving less power loss. This is done to improve the user experience with longer battery lifetime and better motor performance. Unfortunately it has the drawback that it is not able to start 2 or more LPF Medium motors at the same output. As I will explain below this is not a problem with the motor driver, but a known issue with the LPF Medium motor.

The raw motor currently used in the LPF Medium motor internally contains a relatively large capacitor (1 uF) across each of the 3 motor coils. This is done by the motor manufacturer for noise reduction.

We knew that this would be an issue with the new CMOS motor driver (DRV8833). Since it can source a very high inrush current the over current protection will kick in sooner (typically after 2,25 us with a current exceeding 3,3 A). At start up the motor driver will first charge the input capacitance. With 2 or more LPF Medium motors at the same output this can trigger the over current protection. It will repeatedly try to start the motors and you will only hear a singing noise.

For many reasons we have been searching for a higher quality solution for the LPF Medium motor and we now have an approved new raw motor. It has better quality commutation and only 1nF across the terminal. An updated LPF Medium motor will be released during 2013.

Backwards compatibility is of very high importance when we choose new solutions. In this case our decision was that the advantages of the new motor driver together with the fact that we would update the LPF Medium motor would compensate for the inconvenience with the current LPF Medium motor.

We hope this is not causing too many limitations to your model creativity.


Gaute Munch

The LEGO Group


We guess the Tech Platform team has been frantically searching for a replacement for the raw Medium motor, in the last weeks.
Although the problem has been identified a the solution as well, we will remain with a legacy of 'not so compatible PF elements'. At this point and thinking on the possible remedy, I can only wish TLG will make the new version of the PF M-motor easily distinguishable from the original version actually in the market.

We had already two versions of the PF IR Receiver (with firmware differences only) and two versions of the large Technic Linear Actuator, which are inconvenient enough to distinguish...


5 comments:

Joakim Andersson said...

I'm a bit confused by the statement that the V2 receiver "is currently only available through the 9398 set".

I came out of my dark ages in September this year, getting myself the 8043 excavator. With that, I got two IR receivers which both clearly have the V2 marking on them...

Are the people at LEGO confused, or doesn't my 8043 set exist? :P

Fernando Correia said...

@Joakim Andersson

Despite the V2 was released with the 9398, it was developed to replace the previous versions. Thus we can expect to see it with any new sets produced, using this element.

The TLG statement may sound misleading, but likely it is correct.
I guess the 8043 sets produced in late 2012 may have used also the V2 as the previous stock exhausted.
Although the Excavator is about to be descontinued this year and thus not produced anymore. If you look at LEGO Shop@Home you will notice it is marked as "Retiring soon" / "Sold Out"

Guess this explains it all. ;)

TBS said...

Oh great... at least TLG tries to fix it. For distuingishing of the old and new M-Motors easily they can switch the colors. i.e. LBG-Front / DBG Back.

But from my point of view, this action is nonsense, since the L-Motor seems the be created as a replacement for the M-Motor. Its has almost the eaxact same size and 50% more torque... and way better connections. So in a way the M-ones rule itself out.

The money and resources for redesigning, could better be directed into creating a PF-S or-XS Motor finally. (with a design also connecting to the linear actuators - if i can speak out a wish.)

just my cents.
Tom.

Jetro said...

@Tom - don't rule out the M motor just yet. There is LEGO uside Technic and even if they decide to replace the M motor with the L motor in all future Technic sets, the M motor has a better form-factor for CREATOR etc.

Fernando Correia said...

Also the M-motor is one module shorter than L-motor, and this one also requires half modules extra space for each side from one direction.
In practice it may require a considerable more space in a variety of situations than the M-motor.

Don't believe the L could be seen as a replacement of the M one. Also because of its studed connectivitiy, like Jetro did mention.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...



© 2007-2014 TechnicBRICKs
TechnicBRICKs contents may be sporadically updated, if the authors finds further relevant info about a certain post, or content/spell mistakes. Hence please don't be surprised if you find few changes at later visits, relative to a previous read.

TechnicBRICKs often shows other peoples' creations and/or images. We always try to credit the author(s) and link to their main publishing website, and if possible with their name in real life.
Since this is not always possible, we request that if you find something here that is yours or from someone you know, you leave a comment on the respective post and claim the authorship.

TechnicBRICKs is optimized for Firefox 16.0 and 1600x1200 resolution displays or wider.

LEGO® is a trademark of The LEGO Group of companies which does not sponsor, authorize or endorse this blog.
LEGO, the LEGO logo, the Brick and Knob configurations, the Minifigure and MINDSTORMS, are registered trademarks of The LEGO Group.
Original LEGO images are copyrighted by The LEGO Group and are used here in accordance with their fair play policy.
You can visit the official LEGO® website at www.LEGO.com.